New Credit Card Customers vs. Tenured Credit Card Customers

In addition to identifying the overall weighted^ drivers of customer satisfaction within a given industry, the flexibility of the J.D. Power Index Model can also pinpoint differences based on consumer behaviors and demographics. For example, Rewards may be a vital part of the experience for one segment of credit card customers, while Card Terms may be more important to a different segment of customers.

With regards to the credit card experience, the drivers of customer satisfaction differ between new and tenured cardholders. Card Terms (e.g. fees, rates, credit limits) is a bigger driver of satisfaction amongst new cardholders (less than one year with issuer), while Billing/Payment and Interaction (e.g. website, call center representative) are bigger drivers of satisfaction amongst tenured cardholders (one year or more with issuer).

Analysis of data from the 2014 Credit Card Satisfaction Study also finds that most issuers struggle to maintain satisfaction with cardholders as the tenure of their relationship increases. As displayed in the chart below, a majority of issuers receive ‘above-average’ satisfaction amongst new primary cardholders (less than one year). However, only three issuers have above-average satisfaction amongst tenured cardholders (one year or more). This seems to indicate that the ‘shine’ of a new credit card wears off quickly, and it is important for issuers to focus efforts on maintaining satisfaction throughout the life of the relationship.

ccs blo posit

^For each industry measured, J.D. Power utilizes a multi-regression analysis to identify and prioritize the primary drivers of customer satisfaction.

Bookmark and Share

Leave a Reply

 

 

 

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>